CT: "Is the president
finally ready to fight this war or not?"
Tuesday, December 01, 2009
Length: 4:16
LARGE (49.6 MB)
-----
SMALL (5.2 MB)
Less than 30 minutes prior to the speech,
Campbell Brown introduces "the best foreign policy
team on television" -- Michael, Christiane
Amanpour, Nic Robertson, Barbara Starr, and Chris
Lawrence.
WOLF
BLITZER: We're here with our top analysts, our top
reporters, many of whom have spent quite a bit of
time in Afghanistan. They know this terrain quite
well. Campbell, there is no doubt that this is going
to be the president's war as of tonight.
CAMPBELL BROWN: It is indeed, Wolf. And with me now,
I think the most appropriate place to start, probably
the best foreign policy team in television. But you
guys have all been there. You've been on the ground
in Afghanistan. You've spent a lot of time with the
military commanders. Christiane Amanpour, start us
off with what you think he must convey tonight, given
the vast number of audiences he is speaking to.
CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR, CNN CORRESPONDENT: He's got to
convey that he is in it for the long-term in terms of
getting the job done, as he himself has said.
Obviously he has a domestic constituency here so he's
talking about starting to withdraw. But the last
thing people out there want to hear is an exit
strategy or a definite timeline. They want to hear
that the Taliban is going to be beat back.
Because the first thing people out there want is
security. And then they want to hear that there is
going to be some kind of development so that they can
actually have some kind of better livelihood. This is
not going to be won by bombs and bullets alone. This
is going to be by bread and butter, better
livelihoods, books, education, that kind of thing.
And that's what is going to have to happen.
BROWN: But Nic Robertson, you have been there. Is
this something that can be achieved given the
timeline that's being laid out?
NIC ROBERTSON, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL
CORRESPONDENT: If the timeline is 18 months to see
significant improvement so that you can start drawing
down, that seems to be very rapid and perhaps overly
ambitious at this particular stage. We've been told
now it's a generational thing that is going to happen
in Afghanistan. Education takes time to trickle
through. Building up security forces takes time. The
police in particular are very weak. Getting rid of
the corruption within the government is no overnight
fix either. So it does seem as if this is a very
tight timeline to really be wanting to draw down
sufficient numbers to show that we are actually
coming out.
BROWN: And Barbara Starr, you are leaving, I know,
for Afghanistan I believe in the morning. You've
talked to the military commanders. They've been
briefed on this. They know the numbers that he is
talking about, the commitment he is willing to make.
Is it enough in their view?
BARBARA STARR, CNN PENTAGON CORRESPONDENT: Well, the
question is, is it enough for the young soldier or
marine on the ground. The young kid who's got one
more nighttime patrol, one more ambush to live
through, one more convoy through insurgent territory.
They're going to want to hear what is in this speech
that is going to make their job more safe, and what
about the 30,000 troops that are going? What is in
this that is going to make it possible for them to
win?
BROWN: And Chris Lawrence, you're just back. You've
been talking to them. Is that what they want to hear?
Is that what they want the president to convey?
CHRIS LAWRENCE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I think they'll be
looking beyond this speech to see what their
commanders say about how this is going to affect
their particular unit. Those teams that go out and
clear the roads of IEDs, will they be able to get
more eyes on the roads so the insurgents don't come
and replant the bombs after they go through? It's
that level of detail that I think the individual
soldiers are going to be looking at after this
speech.
BROWN: And quickly, Michael Ware, our cynic. You have
been known to be our cynic on occasion. How
optimistic are you?
MICHAEL WARE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well, it depends. Is
the president finally ready to fight this war or not?
We've seen eight years of America failing to fight
the war in Afghanistan, either on the development
front or tactically on the battlefield. Now sending
an extra 30,000 troops is the first start. But that
in a vacuum is not enough.
And something else we need to be keenly aware of, and
we may or may not hear this tonight from the
president. The war is not ultimately going to be won
or lost in Afghanistan. You've got to get Pakistan to
stop tacitly supporting the Taliban. To do that, you
need to allay Pakistan's fears about India, because
India essentially backs the Afghan government. So
there is so many moving pieces. We even see the
subtle hand of Iran in there helping the Taliban.
There are so many moving pieces here that just
sending troops alone just to fight is not going to be
enough.
BROWN: Before we get into some of the politics on
this, because there is so much more to talk to, I
want to go back to Wolf to get a sense, Wolf, from
what people on the ground who are there now are
feeling about tonight as well.